Weasel Words
... is it a fallacious argument to object that 'a million people will be disappointed' (out of a total of possibly hundreds of millions) Not necessarily — it depends on how the “million people will be disappointed” claim is being used in the argument. When it is fallacious It becomes a fallacy if the argument treats that disappointment as a decisive reason to avoid an action, while ignoring scale or tradeoffs. A few common ways this happens: 1. Appeal to pity / emotion without weighing costs “We can’t cancel the event — a million people will be disappointed.” That frames disappointment as trumping all other factors. If the alternative is preventing harm to 10 million people, or the event costs $2B, then the argument is disproportionate. This is a form of appeal to emotion. 2. Implied false consensus / misleading by numbers “A million people will be disappointed” sounds huge, but if the relevant population is 300 million, that’s 0.33%. Present...