Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds
The fleeting debut and immediate retraction of Google’s Nano Banana 2—a tool that allowed users to generate deepfake satellite imagery within Google Earth—has ignited a firestorm of moral panic. Critics, ranging from investigative journalists to tech ethicists, have seized upon the incident as proof of corporate hubris, pointing to the now-infamous "Don't Be Evil" Google motto as a broken promise. They argue that Google, in its rush to innovate, briefly made it easier to be evil by allowing users to fabricate "evidence" of nuclear plants in Iran, a refugee crisis on the border, or bomb craters in Poland. Yet, this outcry misses the fundamental truth of the motto and the nature of the technology itself. The admonition "Don't Be Evil" was never a corporate pledge of responsibility. It was directed at the user, a warning that the power of the tool is neutral, that the intent behind its use is everything. The blowup of Nano Banana 2 is not a failure of...